Yoga is now taught to soldiers, police officers and members of nationalist movements, and two positions are available on this. One holds that steadied, self-focused attention produces supremacy: a person trained to quiet everything but the self becomes better at dominating others. The other holds that yoga is a neutral tool for calm and focus that serves whatever purpose its user brings to it. Ahiṃsā yoga is where both positions can be tested against the Yoga Sūtra and the Bhagavad Gītā. Dr. Shyam’s explication of those texts shows that both misdescribe Yoga.
Two Positions, One Assumption
Both positions treat yoga as an instrument and judge it by what it produces: calm, focus or domination. That is consequentialist reasoning, on which the end settles what the means are worth.
Dr. Shyam explicates Yoga as the fourth basic ethical theory, alongside virtue ethics, consequentialism and deontology. The three familiar theories each understand the right by way of the good: the good character of the agent, a good end, or a procedure that justifies a good outcome. Yoga reverses the order. Right conduct, which is devotion to the ideal of the Right, named Sovereignty (Īśvara) in the Yoga Sūtra, produces good being, which is autonomy (kaivalya). The question to ask about any practice is therefore what governs the action. The calm or the strength a practice happens to produce does not settle it.
What Ahiṃsā (Ahimsa) and Yama Mean in the Yoga Sūtra (Yoga Sutra)
The Sūtra defines both terms in its own list. Yama is the first limb, rendered in Dr. Shyam’s translation as Universal Obligation, de-colonization (II.29). The Sūtra then lists its content:
> ahiṃsā-satyāsteya-brahmacaryāparigrahā yamāḥ (II.30) > > The requirements of anti-oppression activism are destroying systemic harm (ahiṃsā), thus occupying facts (satya), not depriving others what’s theirs (āsteya), respecting personal boundaries (brahmacarya) and non-appropriation (aparigrahā). (II.30)
Ahiṃsā is therefore the destruction of systemic harm. The common gloss, non-violence understood as gentleness or a refusal of conflict, is not what the text states. The text presents ahiṃsā as a requirement placed on a person who practices Yoga, and as the first of five.
The Sūtra also states the scope of the requirement: it is a Great Duty, to be followed “irrespective of station at birth, country or place, time or custom” (II.31). And it states the effect of being grounded in it: “That (being the yogic activist) is based upon destroying systemic harm, and that has the effect of making opponents renounce their hostility.” (II.35)
What Ahiṃsā (Ahimsa) Yoga Requires
The Yoga Sūtra defines Yoga at I.2 as the control of the moral character of thought, and it defines action in Yoga in three parts:
> tapaḥ svādhyāyeśvara-praṇidhānāni kriyā-yogaḥ (II.1) > > Action in Yoga consists of unconservatism, self-governance and devotion to Sovereignty. (II.1)
Steadied attention enters this definition only as governed by devotion to Sovereignty, the ideal of the Right. Attention steadied in service of an end set from outside, such as victory, order or national greatness, is governed by a good, and the definition does not count it as action in Yoga, whatever the program calls itself. This tells against the defenders. Calm and focus are not what defines Yoga, so a program that trains them does not thereby teach Yoga, and Yoga is not a neutral tool for any purpose.
It tells against the critics as well. Devotion in the Sūtra is owed to Sovereignty, and not to a nation, a caste or an institution, so supremacy is not what Yoga is devoted to.
On the definition above, a soldier’s or an officer’s station does not alter the requirement of II.30. Ahiṃsā yoga is Yoga practiced with the destruction of systemic harm as a requirement of the practice, and a program that teaches breath and attention to people whose work maintains systemic harm does not meet it, however calm those people become.
What the Bhagavad Gītā (Bhagavad Gita) Says About Force
The inference from force to supremacy holds that if yoga is associated with fighting, it serves domination. The Gītā does not support that inference. In Dr. Shyam’s explication, the Mahābhārata sets out what happens when conventional morality breaks down. Conventional morality, whether it is organised around good character, good outcomes or good rules, understands the right by way of the good. That makes it public and codifiable, and it also makes it exploitable. The Kauravas are moral parasites: they use the Pāṇḍavas’ commitment to deference, hospitality and the rules of the dice game to dispossess them.
Krishna’s argument in the Gītā is that what survives this breakdown is the procedural ethic of Yoga, devotion to unconservatism and self-governance, which karma yoga, bhakti yoga and jñāna yoga each present. The justice of the cause and the justice of the conduct then coincide, because both are devotion to the same ideal. The test of an action is whether it is devotion to that procedural ideal or serves moral parasitism, and the presence of force settles neither. A calm, disciplined army or police force serving an unjust cause does not become yogic by being calm.
What an Officer in a Yoga Class Should Ask
A police officer is offered breath control and attention training in a program sold as yoga, and asks whether it is Yoga. The Sūtra lists the eight limbs, which, if we explicate, we find to be Patañjali’s non-ideal theory (II.26): what a person does when the ideal practice meets impediments. They are not a curriculum.
> The eight limbs of yoga are: 1. (yama: Universal Obligation) de-colonization, 2. (niyama: personal Obligation) personal commitment to Yoga, 3. (āsana: posture) occupying space of practice, 4. (prāṇāyāma: breath control) controlling boundaries, 5. (pratyāhāra: withdrawal) releasing attention, 6. (dhāraṇā) content support, 7. (dhyāna) free exploration, and 8. (samādhi: conclusion) inferential synthesis. (II.29)
Breath control, the fourth limb, taught without the first two is one item removed from this list. The answer to the officer’s question depends on what the officer’s work does. Where it destroys systemic harm, occupies facts, does not deprive others, respects boundaries and does not appropriate, the discipline is Yoga whatever the uniform. The Sūtra states the effect of such practice: the person grounded in destroying systemic harm makes opponents renounce their hostility (II.35). Where the work maintains systemic harm, calm leaves that unchanged. Dr. Shyam’s explication gives this answer, and neither position reaches it.
Why Study Yoga Philosophy? To Know What Your Work Is Serving
Whether breathing and attention training offered to soldiers, police or nationalist movements is yoga is a question about your own work and income if you teach it, and about what you are joining if you take it. Studying the Sūtra gives a criterion you can use. For Yoga, ahiṃsā is doing harm to harmful regularities, and yama is a Universal Obligation, so one question applies in every role: does this work disrupt systemic harm or maintain it? The eight limbs are what a person does when the ideal practice meets impediments (II.26, II.29), and where the work destroys systemic harm the Sūtra states the result: opponents renounce hostility (II.35). Where it maintains harm, the training is not yoga whatever it is called. That ties autonomy to livelihood, so your income need not depend on making an institution more efficient at harm. Yoga is not a neutral tool.
Yoga Is Measured by What Governs the Action
Any program that offers calm to people in uniform raises one question that the Sūtra settles: what governs what those people do with it. Dr. Shyam sets out Yoga as an ethical theory in Yoga: Anticolonial Philosophy (Singing Dragon, 2024), and his scholarly work is at shyam.org. The Yoga Moral Philosophy course at yogaphilosophy.com works through these texts. Dr. Shyam’s coaching practice, Philosophit (philosophit.com), applies his philosophical training to personal decisions.

